by definition

topic posted Mon, November 7, 2005 - 8:39 AM by  Unsubscribed
You can be 5' tall, weigh 300 pounds, and still be petite, right?
posted by:
Unsubscribed
  • Re: by definition

    Mon, November 7, 2005 - 1:25 PM
    no offense, but i don't think so.
    • Unsu...
       

      Re: by definition

      Mon, November 7, 2005 - 8:40 PM
      None taken. And I'm not wrong. The limit is actually 5'4" tall. I verified this with the folks in the Petite's section of Macy's. This website also corroborates:

      www.sideroad.com/Beauty/pe...othes.html

      Here's another one.

      www.shortsupport.org/Resourc...men.html

      I mean, I know this almost clinical definition is what none of us have in mind, but for specificity's sake...
      • Re: by definition

        Tue, November 8, 2005 - 12:25 PM
        to me petite is a reference to body size as well as height...i would be more likely to consider a moderately tall thin woman petite, rather then a curvy shorter woman...Just my opinion, again not trying to offend anyone.
        • Re: by definition

          Tue, November 8, 2005 - 6:14 PM
          a 5-ft. tall woman weighing 300 pounds would be considered deathly obese.

          in my head, that kinda negates the "petite" moniker altogether.

          but that's just me thinking out loud...
      • Re: by definition

        Wed, November 9, 2005 - 4:23 AM
        I might not have the oficial def on hand but thats not mine, and in mine you can be 10'

        it;s abaut the look
        • Unsu...
           

          Re: by definition

          Wed, November 9, 2005 - 1:07 PM
          I know what I like to imagine when I'm thinking "petite," even if the definition does stipulate any size for a woman 5'4" tall or less. I'm not into spherical women. I don't think any of us are.

          And that's all I was going to say. But this last post is essentially saying, "I don't care what the book says, I'm writing my own dictionary." I know many republicans who think like that.
          • Re: by definition

            Wed, November 9, 2005 - 1:43 PM
            it's really simple actually.

            when you are talking about clothes size (ie Macy's) "Petite" means "short". that's it. there are plus sized petites. someone can be a size 20 but still need a petite becuase if they don't buy that then the pants will drag on the floor and the sleves will be 4 inches too long. so by definition in the clothing market - petite merely means SHORT. not short and thin.

            sociologically however, petite is normally considered small all around. thin as well as short.
  • Re: by definition

    Sun, November 13, 2005 - 11:53 AM
    petite - adjective (Cambridge Univ. Dictionary)
    1 APPROVINGLY If a woman or girl is petite, she is small and thin in an attractive way: She was dark and petite, as all his wives had been.
    2 of a clothing size that is for small women

    The Cambridge definition captures how I've always interpreted "petite:" small and thin. And as far as that goes, I see no conflict between being "thin" and being "curvy;" the terms are not mutally exclusive!
    • Re: by definition

      Mon, November 14, 2005 - 11:15 AM
      >>"I see no conflict between being "thin" and being "curvy;" the terms are not mutally exclusive!"<<

      Well, you've probably never asked a woman who sees herself as "curvy" if there's a 'conflict' in the terms. ;-)
      • Re: by definition

        Mon, November 14, 2005 - 2:23 PM
        reminds me of a discussion of another conflict - or it could be the same one - the question: "do i look fat?" - even if the woman is 15 pounds under weight or 1 pound over - does not have a correct answer. you could say no, but she will disagree and not be content with whatever your answer is either way.

        if you say curvy, it will be misinterpreted as "fat". if you say 'you look fine' - misinterpreted as "fat". if you say 'you look perfect just the way you are"...."fat". heaven forbid you should say something like "don't worry about it."

        when that question is asked, run. run far, run fast. return with expensive gifts, preferably jewels.

        there's your conflict! lol

        a petite (4'10" @ 94 lbs.) woman that i lived with/dated for a few years - beautiful lady from hawaii with a great figure - i commented and complimented on her great legs and how nice her posterior was, the great "shape" it has, (she's a professional dancer) that it looked like a great piece of artwork. she thinks she's got a fat butt and thick legs (her words.) ??wtf??
        • Re: by definition

          Mon, November 14, 2005 - 5:39 PM
          women are often insecure with their bodies and need reassurance. i, personally, am underweight and it doesn't matter who tells me that i am NOT too thin, i still feel like my bones protrude out everywhere. i think that TV and magazines have a way of making the "real" woman feel imperfect, regardless of which way the scale sways.

          just look her in the eye, tip her chin up, and tell her "you look gorgeous."

          she may disagree with you, but she still heard it, and that's what really matters.
          • Re: by definition

            Mon, November 14, 2005 - 8:31 PM
            i have a friend that is a taller girl, but very svelte. she hates it when people ask her if she's bulimic or anorexic or whatever. she eats like a horse, she's athletic and toned, but still...slender beyond anyone else's "thin" jealousy levels. people told her that she should be a model - she tried it for a while and hated it. got into another type of "beauty contest" - broadcasting. she's still a "skinny mini" - but pretty nonetheless. i wish i had that problem. i can't comment or compliment her - it makes her angry as well. so i just don't even bring it up! problem solved!
            lol
            • Re: by definition

              Mon, November 21, 2005 - 9:02 AM
              >> she hates it when people ask her if she's bulimic or anorexic or whatever. <<

              ?? You make it sound like this puzzles you.
              • Re: by definition

                Mon, November 21, 2005 - 11:24 AM
                women as a whole puzzle me, but i guess that's what draws me to them and why i find a majority of them intriguing!

                the fact that she's amazingly pretty and yet, people still try to find something wrong with her is what's puzzling. i can't say that i blame her for getting agitated when people ask her such silly things. puzzling, yet understandable.

                kinda sorta like when people ask me if i am black after i tell them that mom is from trinidad.
          • Re: by definition

            Mon, November 14, 2005 - 11:07 PM
            "NOT too thin"?

            Why don't you just say chubby?
            You are chubby!
            Actually not chubby, just plain fat.
            Say it!

            Also I want you to go to gym every other day and start on a diet.

            :).


            • Re: by definition

              Tue, November 15, 2005 - 7:36 AM
              *looks at self in mirror*

              oh yeah i'm totally fat.

              LMAO
              • Re: by definition

                Tue, November 15, 2005 - 11:11 PM
                yeah, my ex used to complain about being "fat" when she had a 24 inch waist (5'9" too, hardly petite). it's just a fact of life.
                • Re: by definition

                  Wed, November 16, 2005 - 12:39 PM
                  All women should be content with the body they have when they are eating right and getting a healthy amount of exercise. This is advice that I myself need to listen to: I've fought a life-long battle with anorexia that I inherited from my mother (also a petite woman). I'm not active in the disease now, but there's always an internal temptation to call myself a fat-ass when I see my reflection, which usually leads to a relapse.
      • Re: by definition

        Mon, February 20, 2006 - 1:39 PM
        Thom: "I see no conflict between being "thin" and being "curvy;" the terms are not mutally exclusive!"
        Tattoo: "Well, you've probably never asked a woman who sees herself as "curvy" if there's a 'conflict' in the terms. ;-)"

        Tom... You didn't seriously mean to imply that a woman who's "curvy" CANNOT also be "thin," did you? You misinterpreted, "not mutually exclusive," correct? If something is "mutually exclusive" it necessitates a choice between possibilities... "either 'this' or 'that'"... "you can't have 'one' if you have the 'other'!" So when I said the terms "thin" and "curvy" are NOT mutually exclusive, all I'm saying is, both can exist! ;)

Recent topics in "Petite women"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
anyone want to be moderator? ♥C r i s t a♥ 3 July 27, 2008
Petite girls in Bondage LatexHer 4 June 16, 2008
women's clothing sizes T. 8 December 23, 2007
ok i need to vent. ♥C r i s t a♥ 33 December 18, 2007